The Space Policy Show
The Aerospace Corporation’s Center for Space Policy and Strategy hosts this series to bring our policy experts together with thought leaders, government, academia and professionals from throughout the space community to discuss current trends and views. Go to https://csps.aerospace.org/events to subscribe for webcast reminders or find us on YouTube. #TheSpacePolicyShow
The Space Policy Show
Ep. 180: Think you know GPS?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) are operated by multiple nations – the U.S., Europe, China, Russia – and even include region-specific systems, but GPS has been the “gold standard” for decades. How do satellites pass on PNT (position, navigation and timing) to our everyday lives, and what are the augmentations and alternatives to satellite-enabled services? Geopolitical conflict has brought PNT to the forefront as an indispensable asset to drone warfare, and the future of resilience is being explored. In this episode, Colleen Stover (CSPS) hosts Lisa Dyer, Executive Director of the GPS Innovation Alliance, to discuss how the trade association is approaching these questions and looking to the future of technology and policy.
Available by video or podcast.
Learn more about the history of GPS in the CSPS paper U.S. Policy Decisions That Shaped Civil and Commercial Use of GPS.
The Space Policy Show is produced by The Aerospace Corporation’s Center for Space Policy and Strategy. It is a virtual series covering a broad set of topics that span across the space enterprise. CSPS brings together experts from within Aerospace, the government, academia, business, nonprofits, and the national labs. The show and their podcasts are an opportunity to learn about and to stay engaged with the larger space policy community.
Subscribe to our YouTube channel to watch all episodes!
There's a there's a phrase assisted GNSS that's used largely in the cellular community, the people who make cell phones, that's one of the ways that they call it. I always when I hear that question, or I what when I hear alt PNT, that always leads me to ask additional questions. What kind of technology is it GPS independent? Um is it a marketing stage? Is it RD? When do you think he'll be available? Is it world with military customers?
SPEAKER_01Hello everyone. Welcome to the Space Policy Show, brought to you by the Center for Space Policy and Strategy, part of the Aerospace Corporation. I'm Colleen Stover, and I'm here today with a special guest. We're gonna talk about uh GPS, no GNSS, no, no, no, GPS. We're gonna talk about all that stuff, right?
SPEAKER_00Sounds great. Yeah, perfect.
SPEAKER_01So, Lisa, can you please introduce yourself to our audience and a little bit? You are the lead for the GPS Innovation Alliance, and I'd like to learn a little bit more about that too.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Thank you for having me. Really, it's an honor to be here. I uh my name's Lisa Dyer, I'm the executive director of the GPS Innovation Alliance. We're a trade association consisting of companies that build satellites, so Lock Geek Martin, who builds the GPS satellites. We're excited and proud to have two companies, commercial companies, that are building commercial versions of GPS called Trust Point and Zona. And then our other six members are companies that build components that go into receivers and devices, or receivers and devices, ranging from general dynamics mission systems who build those receivers and devices that go on the satellites in space, to commercial companies like Apple, Garmin, Trimble, Deer, who are building things in our everyday lives that we use every day and think nothing of it, and don't realize that a lot of what's driving those services and products are GPS and other global navigation satellite system signals. We also have a company from Canada called Novatel, which is a part of Hexagon, that builds some components that go into these receivers and devices. It's a really interesting mix of companies and each learning from each other. The receiver and device manufacturers know what to do to take those signals. The companies building the satellites get to learn how are people actually using these signals and how have they made these multi-billion dollar companies out of these signals that we are delivering with our satellites. This is a great story.
SPEAKER_01I
SPEAKER_00can't wait to tell it.
SPEAKER_01Well, now you said Deere, as in John Deere.
SPEAKER_00John Deere, yes. Technically they changed the name to Deere and Company, but everybody knows them as John Deere and that iconic green and yellow.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course, of course. Um so tell me about um, we're gonna talk a little bit more about uh the kind of commercial um GPS um versus you know government-owned GPS, but your your website has um some amazing things on it in terms there's a there's one one of the pages is called GPS in action on the website,
SPEAKER_00right?
SPEAKER_01And I scrolled down that, and all of the different ways that GPS enables life was fascinating. Um so it people and I know people like to think that they know everything, but there's they don't so the things that I wrote down, the the weather, the emergency response, um precision, kind of fishing, ranching, farming, forestry, that type of thing for geolocating and being able to save on on water, on um on uh fertilizers, different things like that, being able to track your animals. Um, and of course, think of all the fuel that I have personally saved, a lot of fuel dollars on navigation,
SPEAKER_00right?
SPEAKER_01Right, and not not going the long way home.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Um,
SPEAKER_01and that that's the same for for um for airplanes, for shipping, all those things, right? Um, the other things, um, you know, I don't use a scooter. Do you use a scooter?
SPEAKER_00I am not brave enough to get on one yet. But
SPEAKER_01scooters and bike shares that are all over the country right now,
SPEAKER_00yes.
SPEAKER_01Um, using those. And then um, you know, even remote health and remote education um in remote areas of the world. It's it's fascinating.
SPEAKER_00It really is, it really is. And most of us forget also that there are some atomic clocks on board these GPS satellites that transmit timing signals. Not only do those timing signals allow the engineers to put you at a specific position on the earth, but they also synchronize financial transactions, the electrical grid, uh cellular communications such as Wi-Fi, any cryptographic functions, so any over-the-air updates, updates to your phones, things like that. So that's a whole nother side of GPS that most people don't even think about, but is absolutely essential to our day-to-day life.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, and it's gonna continue to be. So we need them those signals to be protected.
SPEAKER_00We do, we do. Can't wait to talk more about that.
SPEAKER_01Um, so uh GPS is just one um system of GNSS. And GNSS is the the global navigation satellite systems, GPS is one of them, um, and all of this is under the umbrella of PNT, position navigation and timing.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01But GPS used to be a military,
SPEAKER_00yes.
SPEAKER_01Um and now it's civilian. Can you give us some history about that particular US system?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. So if you talk, if you talk to Dr. Brad Parkinson, who was
SPEAKER_01He's been on the show.
SPEAKER_00Oh, awesome, but he should be. He was really the leader of a number and worked with a number of remarkable individuals who came together and ended up providing to us what was the foundations of GPS. It's gone through many, many iterations through them, but he and Gaylord Green, there are a number of individuals who are just absolutely phenomenal people who created this, one of I think America's best innovations ever, right? Yeah, and
SPEAKER_01GPS the gold standard. Right, right.
SPEAKER_00So they were, of course, working for the military, for the Air Force. Um they brought in some NATO officers to help them as they were developing these systems and brought it along. Dr. Parkinson will say that this so their GPS, let me take a step back. GPS transmits signals that are encrypted, designed for the military and military-approved users. But they also transmit what are called civil signals that anyone in the world can pick up if they have the right C receiver. They also made the interface control documents so you could understand what the signals look like. All that information is freely available so that anybody can build to those signals and use them most effectively. That's pretty remarkable. We had some tremendous, GPS is also another story about innovation and entrepreneurship. We had some amazing folks who said who became aware of these signals, went out, picked them up, and said, I can do something with this and I can make some pretty amazing products. We're excited to have a couple of the original companies that started in those early days in the early 80s. Garmin and Trimble, yeah, both of them. Um, those founders, the founders of those companies, two people in Garmin, one Charlie Trimble for Trimble, they were some of those early pioneers who said, I can do something with them. And both Garmin and Trimble are multi-billion dollar companies today that have started with GPS and they've learned to integrate other signals and other technologies together to pair with GPS to create some incredible products and services that we just we just they're on our wrist, they're on our boat, they're on construction equipment, in surveying equipment everywhere. Some of those very uses that you talked about. Some incredible stories there.
SPEAKER_01And so so the the military version is still used today in terms of um having kind of a more secure, maybe more precise, only used for the dedicated to for military use, for national security use. Um, and then the civilian um kind of side of it. I know that back in the kind of 90s there was a lot of um tension between DOD, um, Department of Defense, and DOT, Department of Transportation, who was really vying for it for kind of air, air flight safety.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01Right? There was that kind of aspect. In fact, we have a CSPS paper written about the history of um uh GPS called US Policy Decisions that shaped civil and commercial use of GPS from May 2025. Encourage people to read it. It's by Dr. Brian Whedon, and he really lays out some really interesting kind of um decadal looks at the decisions made going from being exclusively military to um you know uh an air uh, well, not an accident, uh Korean air flight being shot down um by Russia in the 80s, and then that kind of decision of like, hey, wait a minute, we need to maybe the flight had kind of gone off course
SPEAKER_00a little
SPEAKER_01bit.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01And they didn't know that they were off course. And so that kind of really introduced the idea of this wonderful technology to be used for civil purposes as well, right?
SPEAKER_00It did. President Reagan's administration uh came out swiftly soon after that airline was that airliner was shot down. Uh, he got on television that night, the great communicator came out and talked about how irresponsible it was for the Soviet Union to shoot down a civilian airliner. And a few days later, his spokesperson came to came to the podium and said, We're going to make this system, the signals that it has, safer for air navigation so that we don't have another tragic accident like this again.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And but but there was a kind of selective availability.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Can
SPEAKER_01you tell us what that tell us what about that a little bit?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. This
SPEAKER_01is fascinating to me, the history. That's why I'm asking.
SPEAKER_00It is. It's it's amazing. The military was not wild about the idea of providing precise signals that GPS could deliver. So, in non-technical terms, what they did is they fuzzed it up instead of the two-meter that today we get about on average two-meter resolution accuracy in one direction for where you're located on the earth. And uh they fuzzed it up into about a hundred meters accuracy, which is still better than nothing. Oh,
SPEAKER_01I would have missed my turn, though.
SPEAKER_00Yes, you would have missed your turn in a lot of other really great innovations had President Clinton not decided to remove that fuzzing up of that particular signal. It also was somewhat brought about, and I think Dr. Whedon touches on this in his paper, that some companies were actually defeating selective availability. In fact, when I first met you a couple weeks ago, a gentleman stopped me and said, I was one of those people who defeated selective availability, and the Defense Department was like, How did you do that? Um there. And it was
SPEAKER_01getting around it, unpacking it. Okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, unpacking it. So from a technical standpoint, it wasn't providing that assurance that DOD was looking for, and then President Clinton's decision to go ahead and remove selective availability in May of 2000 just unleashed some of these very precise innovations that many of our member companies took advantage of.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's it, right? It's I mean, if that was in 2000, that's when it really started all taking off, didn't it? It
SPEAKER_00really did.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, smartphones and apps and and um lots of different uses, yeah. Um so GPS is only one of the one of the tools out there.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01Right. Um it's it's used as a PNT. I know that I wanted to ask you about this kind of alternate. You mentioned something about um some of about how some of your members use not just GPS but other kind of sensors and and different things to kind of GPS that kind of strengthens them, um, their their use cases, if you will.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01What is alternate PNT?
SPEAKER_00That's a great question. Or or resilient PNT is another phrase that people use a lot. And there's I you know, there's a policy document from the first Trump administration that talks about alternate forms of position navigation and timing systems. So PNT is really describing the types of signals that come from GPS, tells you your position, a little extra engineering, it tells you how to get from A to B to C, and then the timing signal that comes off of those specialized clocks that are on the satellites. We there are alternative PNT systems available in space, um, on the ground, in other areas that provide different signals that are available for people to use with varying levels of accuracy, varying levels of continuity, availability, and varying levels of integrity. One of the things that the FAA, actually the Federal Aviation Administration, measure measures GPS signals on are those four uh four ideas, the continuity of the signal, the availability, the integrity, and the accuracy. They do that because they have mandated the use of GPS and space-based augmentation systems for use in aviation, and the international civil community has also followed suit and said, we're going to use this for performance-based navigation and to enhance air safety. So now within an aircraft, there are up to 17 different systems and subsystems, depending upon the model of the aircraft, that rely on those GPS signals that first come into the aircraft to help them operate and help the aircrew provide better services and improve safety to their passengers.
SPEAKER_01So, are you saying that the GPS signal will come into the aircraft and then other sensors within the aircraft will test against it just to make sure that things are all correct?
SPEAKER_00It comes into the receiver that's on board the aircraft, and then that where they are, those fixes are replicated through the other system. So it's it's the one receiver, and then seven those other 16 systems in the aircraft are taking that information to help them perform the role that they're designed to perform. So the flight management system tells the pilot where they are, displays where they are and where they're headed, ground proximity warning systems will tell you, or terrain awareness warning systems. They'll figure out what's in front of you and in in different areas. And if you're coming close to something at hazard, they'll say pull up, pull up, or avoid, avoid. You know, there's kind of this wild alarm goes off that gets the attention of the aircrew.
SPEAKER_01I'm sure I've seen that in a movie.
SPEAKER_00Yes, top gun. Yes, that's a great example of that kind of system. Um, but yeah, they use that information in in all of those different systems. Some are safety critical systems, other other things are like onboard Wi-Fi that they use. Right, right, right. Right.
SPEAKER_01But and and there's also in terms of the, you know, so resilient um PNT or resilient GPS or alt alt um PNT, I mean, like there's they're actually talking about literally hard wires as well, right? Not just sensors, like like an alternate to a backup to GPS would be something hardwired. Or I remember reading in 2016 the Navy started teaching uh cadets how to use the sextant again.
SPEAKER_00Yes,
SPEAKER_01you know, yes, this is the alt p this is alt PNT, right?
SPEAKER_00Right, right. Yes, there I you know, aircraft also have inertial measurement units in board on board.
SPEAKER_01Um
SPEAKER_00and there are IMUs, and I'm not sure I got that IM part right, but IMUs in board that work with the GNS, the GPS receiver to help with navigation. Um some other systems pop up uh other you know magnetometers, there are barometers within an iPhone or other cell phone device that provides assistant GPS types of location information. So there are a lot of other things that complement, supplement GPS as it's being used. Alternative systems are more are technologies that, in my interpretation, they're trying to operate completely independent of GPS.
SPEAKER_01I see. Okay.
SPEAKER_00There are there are some questions about the technologies and whether they can be completely independent. Do they still need that timing signal, for instance? But can they develop something that's completely independent that doesn't require any sort of, you know, a little nudge from GPS to start what they're doing? So a lot of research into quantum, um, magnetic types of position navigation and timing systems, all kinds of things.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00So in various stages of development and marketing that are out there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so that's interesting. So it's about word choice in terms of like alt PNT to in some people, for some people means like replacement.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01And okay, gotcha. And then the other term you used was enhanced GPS or enhanced GNSS?
SPEAKER_00There's a there's a phrase assisted GNSS that's used largely in the cellular community, the people who make cell phones, that's one of the ways that they call it. I always when I hear that question, or I what when I hear alt PNT, that always leads me to ask additional questions. What kind of technology? Is it GPS independent? Um, is it a marketing uh stage? Is it RD? When do you think it'll be available? Is it world, you know, with military customers? Many of our companies, their customers are located around the world. They travel, they live, they work um around the world. So what's the worldwide availability? Is it designed for a localized situation? Uh is it um how is the signal being integrated into the receivers and devices we use to do that? Is that
SPEAKER_01actually compatible with things that exist today? Correct,
SPEAKER_00correct. And if not, what's your plan for getting them integrated into the receiver and device? Are the chipset manufacturers going to have to make changes to their chipsets? Do we need a different antenna? Um, what does that do to the footprint of the receiver and device? Those are so it just leads to more and more questions when when I hear those those types of words.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, thank you. Um I I didn't know I I created such so many questions with Alt BNT.
SPEAKER_00You do, yes.
SPEAKER_01Well, I will I read um recently in a Forbes uh or in a recent article in this year in Forbes, this is quote, uh the future of navigation will not replace GPS, it will surround it.
SPEAKER_00Interesting.
SPEAKER_01That was a kind of alt BNT type thing.
SPEAKER_00Correct, correct. I I agree. Our organization calls that complimentary,
SPEAKER_01right?
SPEAKER_00Complimentary PNT.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And that that's where Trust Point and Zona were excited to see what's coming next for them as they start launching the commercial systems, getting them operational, getting them integrated to into those receivers and devices.
SPEAKER_01Let's can let's talk about um commercial.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01Um commercial GPS does not, it sounds like an oxymoron, right? So commercial GNSS.
SPEAKER_00Correct.
SPEAKER_01That's what we would say. Tell me about how is something like that, what is the business case for something like that when GPS is free?
SPEAKER_00That is a great question. And that's often the question that we hear most often when people start talking about that. So is the water. One of our companies said, so is the water that we can get from a faucet, but the amount of money that people are willing to play, pay for bottled water,
SPEAKER_01yeah,
SPEAKER_00um, enhanced water, just filtered sparkling. Our water is
SPEAKER_01filtered.
SPEAKER_00But people are willing to pay extra for something like that to give those kinds of capabilities. So, you know, a company like Trust Point, one of the things that actually is important to talk about with GPS is the spectrum in which it transmits its signals.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Other global navigation satellite systems by operated by foreign governments are all operating in L band. Uh and um, so Trust Point is actually building a system that will operate in C band. And you know, every part of the electric magnetic spectrum has its pluses and minuses about how well it performs in weather or canyons through fog and rain and uh all of Those different types of atmospheric conditions around them. So Trust Points version is CBAN, which diversifies the spectrum in which PT signals will be available for people to ingest into their receivers and devices. Which
SPEAKER_01adds to resiliency.
SPEAKER_00It does. Right. Absolutely does. Zona is actually the first commercial company to get approval to transmit a commercial signal in the same spectrum where GPS and those foreign GNSS systems are operating. So they are transmitting their signals in L-band as well. They are both low earth orbit systems, so they're closer to the earth.
SPEAKER_01So uh less latency.
SPEAKER_00Correct. So
SPEAKER_01because they're closer, okay.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And their signals are stronger by the time they reach the earth because they're not traveling as far as GPS and the foreign versions of GPS from medium earth orbit. So they are they are really excited about the jam resistance that comes along with the signals that they're transmitting closer to the earth.
SPEAKER_01Interesting, right? So it doesn't get watered out down as much because it's not uh it's not traveling as far. So the idea of having low earth orbit GNSS is the latency, so having having it fast enough and having it strong enough to be jam resistant.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes. Now, because they are operating in low earth orbit, they'll need 250 plus satellites, depending upon the orbits they put them in, to cover the earth completely in the way that GPS is constellation.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and
SPEAKER_00and you need a minimum of 24 of those GPS satellites to cover the the earth. So 24 right now, 31 satellites are on orbit, but 24 versus um 250 plus. Yes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah,
SPEAKER_00yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Oh, that's interesting. So is there um who do they anticipate their customers to be? Do you know?
SPEAKER_00Uh very much very much a mix of commercial as well as government services. You know, both of them talk a lot about the unmanned and autonomous customers out there that they're eager to support with their signals as they're coming along as well.
SPEAKER_01Oh, interesting, yeah. Um, well, uh talking about autonomy,
SPEAKER_00yes,
SPEAKER_01the nature of war has changed in the last few years. Um we see uh drone warfare, the rise of drone warfare, and the need for uh low latency um um instructions or signals. Um can you talk a little bit how how GPS or GNSS in general has been used in um either I know that's in the Ukraine war, I've seen some excellent um visualizations of how drones are used and they rescue drones versus um supply drones versus you know attack drones, sentinel drones, and how they're trying to get um, you know, trying to fight around that and everything. But GPS is a huge part of this kind of warfare, right?
SPEAKER_00It is, it is, and it's evolving. It's an exciting story, and we could talk next week, and there'd be another way, especially in Ukraine. The Wall Street Journal is doing some amazing video articles showing how the frontlines are actually using all of these autonomous drones that you just described. The New York Times is doing some amazing reporting as well. No, I'm always eager to see them. Uh, what's what's evolving over there? The Ukrainians are so inventive. Um,
SPEAKER_01I mean, necessity is the is the is the mother of innovation, right? I mean, they are doing what they need to do, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And you know, in 2024, they did what I classically think of from my time in the Air Force and my time at the State Department as a civilian. They found a Russian spoofer sitting on an abandoned oil platform in the Black Sea, and that spoofer was actually trying to interrupt their operations, and they bombed that spoofer so that it no longer worked. It's a spectacular photo of them actually bombing it.
SPEAKER_01Yes, because spoofing and jamming are the two things that that are of biggest concern, right?
SPEAKER_00Correct. Telling jamming meaning the signal doesn't receive the see the the receiver and spoofer telling you, oh, maybe you're located in Peru or you're located, you know, somewhere else. Exactly, exactly. And and so in some ways you see them evolving and learning how to work with these types of spoofing and jamming technologies and to uh protect their population from these jamming and spoofing technologies. At one point, they were even um sending their drones out with a fiber optic cable attached to them so that they could resist, they could have um protected GPS type of navigation,
SPEAKER_01and
SPEAKER_00then they drop the drop the fiber optic cable and then put their drone on the particular target.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It was uh I've seen some amazing um photos of that, um the fiber optic cables and how the kind of drone-on-drone warfare crisscrossing, trying to go around um the the vulnerability that using GNSS signals provides, trying to get around it and crisscrossing of all these fiber optics, it's now to the point um uh that that uh wildlife birds are making nests out of the fiber optics.
SPEAKER_00Fascinating.
SPEAKER_01Yes, it's a great picture. Well, there's some different pictures of it, but I think it was Washington Post, you know.
SPEAKER_00Fascinating.
SPEAKER_01Um so yeah, so trying to get so and there's I I feel like autonomy kind of complicates things as well. Because when you have uh a drone pilot that's operating um and something goes awry, the signal, they lose a signal, they can, you know, oftentimes they can use um, you know, visual sensing to kind of keep fighting. But when there's autonomy, it's kind of complicated a little bit.
SPEAKER_00It is, and and it's also uh safer that way. If um I saw that I read a really great, or I think it was actually a video of how they're using these autonomous, almost stretchers, to go into a forest and rescue some folks who are on the wounded people on closer to the front
SPEAKER_01line.
SPEAKER_00And so they're able to use that as a form of transportation. Doesn't have a person on it, but gets that person back so they can get the medical care that they need. What an amazing way of thinking differently about autonomy as opposed to the drone that's actually a weapon
SPEAKER_01in and
SPEAKER_00of itself, right? Or dropping weapons that they've managed to affix to the drone.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's many phases of of warfare. Um and I know uh Iran does not use GPS. They um China and Iran in 2021, is that right, signed an agreement for Iran to start using Bedao, which is the Chinese GPS.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yes.
SPEAKER_01Um sorry about that. Bedao, Bedao. We're gonna
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I say China's version of GPS. Yeah. Um
SPEAKER_01but but China's not the only one with a global um navigation system for in satellites. Talk about some of the other players uh around the globe. GPS is just the US one.
SPEAKER_00It is, it is. Europe, I would say, is our closest, most familiar uh Galileo, their Galileo version of their satellite. Um exciting part about Galileo is that they've integrated what's called an authentication signal, where it it's it's sort of like an encrypted app on your phone, but it basically says, this signal I sent to you, it's the correct signal. It's not been spoofed. You can rely on this signal. Oh,
SPEAKER_01interesting.
SPEAKER_00And that's a nice, nice advantage. And so I'm eager to see how it gets integrated into more and more use cases. Can it meet the timeliness that people need for people to rely on that authentication signal? But it's an important enhancement that I wish we had in our GPS product line coming out soon. Um, we also have Russia. Russia's Glow Now system is um their version of GPS. It's been around for many years, not long after GPS came along. Russia over the years has had some quality control issues with some of it, and it hasn't necessarily been its priority system for them to keep in space, but it seems like they're starting to invest again in their system. And then, as you said, China's version of GPS. I won't even try you're brave to try to pronounce it. We're
SPEAKER_01going with Beta. Um,
SPEAKER_00you know, they're operating these systems in geostationary orbit. They have them in MIO, they have them in LEO, and so just a very layered version of the way that their satellites operate. I've seen varying reports that they're they're more like a regional system. Regional systems from Japan and India are optimized for where they are, and I've read that about Bedao. So it's interesting, you know, that Iran is also using their systems in their in their warfare.
SPEAKER_01Right. Well, I I it's hard to kind of surmise exactly what's coming out of out of China,
SPEAKER_00but a
SPEAKER_01challenge to our audience for people to look that up. Um, yeah, I mean I would imagine that having that kind of layered orbits makes it more resilient. And I don't know. I don't I yeah, I don't know.
SPEAKER_00It it does for the people who care a lot about are we gonna have a war in space and and and where will we have that war in space, right? Um if you believe it's gonna happen, then thinking about having satellite systems in different orbits is one element of a resilient system, um, as long as you can afford it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Um, well, things like um, you know, things like being able to deny your adversary or your adversary denying you, um, making sure that the radio frequency spectrum being used is is clean and not with a lot of interference and dedicated um, you know, crypto, you know, uh cyber security and everything, like you were saying, the kind of handshake that Galileo does. I mean, all of these things are important for uh not just national security, but getting your pizza on time.
SPEAKER_00Well, and it that's one of the uh best kept secrets. I I wish it weren't a best-kept secret about GPS, is that the Defense Department actually very much relies on those civil signals. Almost the entirety of the logistics system is outsourced to commercial companies that are using, you know, these are the FedExes, these are the UPS, these are the Atlas Airlines, these are the maritime ships, these are the railroad systems in the United States. The Army can't move, you know, that heavy equipment across the country without the rail system in the United States. And so they, these civil signals need to be also protected from jamming and spoofing to support the military's worldwide logistics and power projection capabilities. Even just getting some of their people overseas, they are flying commercial airlines like you and I
SPEAKER_01do.
SPEAKER_00And so that recognition, I think, is coming along, as well as this idea that we may be using, we may be doing exactly what Ukraine does in a future conflict, which is using low-cost drones. And one of the ways to keep them low cost is to use low-cost commercial GNSS receivers and devices and chipsets in those drones so that it isn't as expensive as dropping a very much more expensive piece of munition somewhere.
SPEAKER_01I want to go back kind of where we started with the Innovation Alliance. Um, you have members from international members now, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um, and but your members also have business all over the world. So, what are you hearing from members about uh what kinds of things they might be looking for in 2027, or what what are the biggest issues for them, or where are your efforts, where are you really pushing?
SPEAKER_00That's a great question. Uh, we were founded really around the idea of making sure that the spectrum that's allocated to GPS is protected and free from harmful interference. And one of the things that we realize when we're talking to most people, they've never heard of RF spectrum, radio frequency spectrum, they've never heard of the electromagnetic spectrum, right? It's it's only for people who need to know about it to understand it. And it was a core reason that the GPS Innovation Alliance was founded many years ago, and it's something we will always keep an eye on at the at the FCC and an international fora, at the ITU, and those kinds of discussions around that.
SPEAKER_01That spectrum is a finite resource. You can only slice it so many times. The smaller your slices, the more chance there is of interference with other actors.
SPEAKER_00And the demands are exceeding the supply.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Yes, very much so.
SPEAKER_01All managed at that international level, though, with licenses and stuff.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And in the United States, the Federal Communications Commission, along with the National Telecommunications Information Administration, which represents the federal uses of spectrum, are coming together to figure out how exactly they are going to provide slices of that spectrum and to which organizations, uses, companies that are seeking it.
SPEAKER_01Some of them very big companies.
SPEAKER_00Some of them very big companies, some of them very powerful companies, some of them very influential. And then there's the federal government users that are using it for national security and public safety that are extremely important. So balancing all those interests, as well as the commercial interests that comes along, is our gigantuan responsibility. One of the latest hot topics that is a big exciting idea for this particular FCC chairman is something called direct to device, where you're not just relying on terrestrial networks to deliver services to someone using a device, but you can use satellites to provide that kind of service. to
SPEAKER_01those the satellite signals going to kind of ground stations and then dispersed terrestrially it's going straight to
SPEAKER_00It's going straight to the device, yes. And so both Apple and Garmin have been doing this in emergency services ways. Apple has something on their iPhone called emergency SOS. And essentially, if you are in the middle, you know, you're in a natural disaster like Hurricane Celine or Milton, and the, you know, the terrestrial infrastructure is devastated, you have the right iPhone, you can point your phone up there and text over a satellite, a global star satellite, that goes to a command center that Apple operates, and it can help try to get it, it can ask emergency services to get where you are actually located
SPEAKER_01and
SPEAKER_00guess where that location comes from. It's coming from their phone, which is picking it up from GPS satellites.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Garmin has a similar directed device type of connectivity through their in-reach devices. These are really little ruggedized devices that are they kind of they have a carabiner that'll hook to your the loop of your hiking gear, or just you can carry it anywhere you need to, pull it out, same same, same idea, and they're starting to add pictures and photo capabilities where you can reach back to their emergency response center in Texas. They've served customers in 200 countries around the world. Um, the Everest climbing season is a hot time for that emergency response center, for instance. But it's it's a form of directed device that kind of established this is a viable business model. Now, satellite companies want to provide that as a different type of service as opposed to terrestrial or complementing the test terrestrial services that you
SPEAKER_01have.
SPEAKER_00Of course, where that spectrum is allocated, there are some people who want to transmit that spectrum near the GPS and the foreign GNSS systems. So we want to make sure that when they're transmitting that spectrum, it is not inadvertently overloading the spectrum that GPS operates in. So that's the kind of spectrum ideas and interests that we we keep an eye out on, especially anywhere near spectrum that's allocated for radio navigation.
SPEAKER_01Okay, okay. So so you guys are you active in the World Radio Conference that I think it's 2027 is coming up?
SPEAKER_00We do. We have a wonderful man named Steve who is one of our consultants who understands the ITU Inside and Out. Really fortunate to have him there to represent the interests of our organization.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So what else besides director device D2D? Um are any of your um are any of your members looking at lunar PNT for kind of cis lunar PNT for when we have the moon bees going?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. General Dynamics space-based um space qualified receivers up there are really trying to take advantage of the side lobes that are available from GPS because you can pick up um GPS on the lunar surface actually, based on depending upon where the satellites are located and where um uh where operations are happening. Of course, there are proposals about establishing a dedicated PT capability for the moon. Um and so exciting, but yeah, General Dynamics is really looking at that, and I'm sure other companies are as well, but it's really interesting what they have been able to discover. Um, and they're just a leading, leading company in space qualified uh GPS receivers. Our members are also really looking at jamming and spoofing,
SPEAKER_01yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Especially outside of conflict zones, especially in the United States, and what that is, what that's doing too, you know. You we asked our PR firm to pull, you know, how many how many articles per year are being published about GPS being jammed and spoofed. One of another not well kept secret, you know, GPS is the brand name.
SPEAKER_01Yeah,
SPEAKER_00but every satellite system that's operating in L band near GPS, including the foreign systems, are getting jammed. But everybody just says GPS is getting jammed. Right.
SPEAKER_01You're you get unfair. It's unfair.
SPEAKER_00Totally, totally. And especially when there are anywhere from 18
unknownto
SPEAKER_0025,000 articles per year that talk about GPS getting jammed and spoofed. Not just in conflict zones, but areas outside of conflict zones.
SPEAKER_01Well, the Arctic I've read has been having kind of an uptick as the ice melts, the shipping lanes are opening up, and um it's becoming more of an important area for geopolitical um competition.
SPEAKER_00It is, yes, very much so, very much so. And European countries that aren't near Russia, aren't necessarily near Ukraine, are also feeling the effects of this. So um we're very concerned about the idea of any the Communications Act actually in the United States prohibits using jamming and spoofing authorized services in the United States. So we're watching very closely about any ideas that might change that, change that calculus and allow for jamming and spoofing to take place in any way, shape, or form.
SPEAKER_01You mean unauthorized jamming or spoofing? Like I'm thinking of hackers.
SPEAKER_00Hackers can do that as well. You know, it doesn't take much to if you're a smart engineer and you can put things together, you can create a low-cat low-cost jammer. Um spoofers, I think, are a little more complicated, but you can buy the components anywhere and put them together.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00To
SPEAKER_01our audience, don't do that.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. We don't want to give you any ideas that haven't already been planted. That's in a lot of those thousands of articles that it's easy to do. Umnecessary, you know. Um we are paying, we're staying very much on top of any action that would allow jamming and spoofing to be to take place. We're also really excited, you know. Just yesterday, the House GPS Caucus had its first appearance. I didn't
SPEAKER_01know there was a House GPS Caucus.
SPEAKER_00Yes, we had one for a while. It was on hiatus through COVID, and we just reconstituted it thanks to Representative Davids and Representative Crank. And so we're excited. To continue that event. So yesterday was our first GPS caucus event of the 119th Congress. We're eager to start again in the 120th Congress. And one of the things that stuck with me from the Garmin representative is how when they start layering in, it's a little bit like the concept of fusion in the Defense Department. You fuse all of these different systems together. The commercial world has been doing that forever as well. They just didn't call it fusion. And so when you put together GPS with computer vision, with remote sensing, with using gravitation fields, measuring the soil surface, you can create precision agriculture capabilities that gives a beautiful map to the farmers of the field. It allows them to almost send out harvesters, planters that are operating nearly autonomously, operating within one to two centimeters of the boundary of the field. And it'll show you season over season the yields that you're getting from particular parts of your field. And it'll tell you, you know, you're doing well in this part, but maybe in this part you're not doing well. And you can start to examine am I planting the wrong crops? Am I do I have more clay in this soil? Do I need to put more water, less water? Do I have a drainage problem over here? And start really being thoughtful about how you maximize the yields. As you mentioned earlier in the podcast, you know, you're you can reduce the amount of seeds, you can reduce the amount of water. The conservation benefits from that are tremendous.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Especially in areas that, you know, as climate, as the climate changes, you know, areas that are getting more water than usual or less water than usual areas.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Absolutely. And Garmin's using it to create some really cool innovations in their watches for elite athletes. Things like tracking your VO2 max, which is how efficient your your body's using the oxygen that it's taking
SPEAKER_01in,
SPEAKER_00is based on your GPS location as you're exercising, how far you're going, how fast, what's your heart rate. They're combining all that information together to give you information on your phone or on your wrist.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00From your wrist that people had to go into a specialized lab and pay tens of thousands of dollars to get these tests. It's now available from your wrist.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So really exciting new innovations that they're looking forward to unveiling to the world as they start to fuse together all these different sources. We didn't even touch on the scientific users out there that are using GPS. Really exciting development is the rollout of the National Spatial Reference Frame. They're taking GPS signals to better measure the shape of the earth. That big blue marble that we have at
SPEAKER_01the end of the day,
SPEAKER_00it's not just
SPEAKER_01a globe.
SPEAKER_00It's not, it is not. And we know that because our scientists tell us that. They're using the GPS signals to see that they're bouncing off the surface of the earth at different different times and measuring those differences.
SPEAKER_01So it's kind of lumpy.
SPEAKER_00It's lumpy, yeah. And it's a wiggle worm. It's constantly shifting. But when they can all agree on a price, precise center of the earth, they can start start to really model the shape of the earth. And that matters that uh when your address is here, people agree that the geo coordinates for your address are the same. But if you're using different reference frames, it might be somewhere across the street or elsewhere. That really matters in a 911 context. You know, I've had to call 911 twice, unfortunately, and fortunately. Um, and in one of those instances, my address did not match the database that they had. So I had to guide people to where I was with that particular medical emergency. So you want to make sure, especially in a 911 scenario, that people can get to your address, that everybody agrees that your address is at a particular geocoordinate. We could talk forever. I know and all of the different ways that GPS is used. And it it's a it's a tremendous story, and I'm honored to share it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I really appreciate you being here. Congratulations on um getting the the band back together, the GPS caucus.
SPEAKER_00Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Um I I also understand that there is a special um uh National GPS Day or International GPS Day that's on October 23rd.
SPEAKER_00Correct. Uh
SPEAKER_01why is the tell me the very nerdy reason it's on October 23rd?
SPEAKER_00Gosh, I'm not sure if I'm nerdy enough to tell you. There are a certain number of megahertz. Yes, yes. How quickly, yes. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Yes, so instead of the the may the force be with you, may the force instead of pie day, we now have another um 1023.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. May the hurts be with you, maybe.
SPEAKER_01I like it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So thank you very much, Lisa, for coming onto the space policy show. I really enjoyed our conversation.
SPEAKER_00Holly, this was great fun. Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh to our audience, thank you for joining. Um, again, all of our shows are at csps.aerospace.org slash space policy show. You can also find the center's deep research there. Um, make sure to follow us on Apple or Spotify if you want to hit up the um the podcasts as they come out. And thank you for joining us today.